| Season | Champion | Rookie of the Year | Most Popular Driver | Season | A. J. Foyt | Mario Andretti | ||||
| Driver | Team | Chassis | Engine | Former Oval Trophy | Former Road Course Trophy | |||||
| 2020 | Scott Dixon (6) |
Chip Ganassi Racing (9) | Dallara (22) | Honda (11) | Rinus VeeKay |
 Alexander Rossi |
2020 | Scott Dixon |
Josef Newgarden |
|
| 2019 | Josef Newgarden
(2) |
Team Penske (5) | Dallara | Chevrolet (7) |
 Felix Rosenqvist |
not awarded | 2019 |  Simon Pagenaud |
Scott Dixon |
|
| 2018 | Scott Dixon |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda | Robert Wickens |
James Hinchcliffe |
2018 | Will Power |
Scott Dixon |
|
| 2017 | Josef Newgarden |
Team Penske | Dallara | Chevrolet |
 Ed Jones |
Conor Daly |
2017 | Hélio Castroneves |
Josef Newgarden |
|
| 2016 | Simon Pagenaud |
Team Penske | Dallara | Chevrolet | Alexander Rossi |
Bryan Clauson |
2016 | Josef Newgarden |
Simon Pagenaud |
|
| 2015 | Scott Dixon |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Chevrolet | Gabby Chaves |
Justin Wilson |
2015 | Juan Pablo Montoya |
Will Power |
|
| 2014 | Will Power |
Team Penske | Dallara | Chevrolet | Carlos Muñoz |
Juan Pablo Montoya |
2014 | Juan Pablo Montoya |
Will Power |
|
| 2013 | Scott Dixon |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda | Tristan Vautier |
Tony Kanaan |
2013 | Hélio Castroneves |
Scott Dixon |
|
| 2012 | Ryan Hunter-Reay |
Andretti Autosport (4) | Dallara | Chevrolet | Simon Pagenaud |
James Hinchcliffe |
Season | A. J. Foyt | Mario Andretti | |
| 2011 | Dario Franchitti (4) |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda | James Hinchcliffe |
Dan Wheldon |
Oval Trophy | Road Course Trophy | ||
| 2010 | Dario Franchitti |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda | Alex Lloyd |
Danica Patrick (6) |
2012 | Ryan Hunter-Reay |
Will Power |
|
| 2009 | Dario Franchitti |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda | Raphael Matos |
Danica Patrick |
2011 | Scott Dixon |
Will Power |
|
| 2008 | Scott Dixon |
Chip Ganassi Racing | Dallara | Honda |  Hideki Mutoh |
Danica Patrick |
2010 | Dario Franchitti |
Will Power |
|
| 2007 | Dario Franchitti |
Andretti Green Racing (3) | Dallara | Honda | Ryan Hunter-Reay |
Danica Patrick |
||||
| 2006 | Sam Hornish, Jr. (3) |
Penske Racing | Dallara | Honda | Marco Andretti |
Danica Patrick |
||||
| 2005 | Dan Wheldon |
Andretti Green Racing | Dallara | Honda | Danica Patrick |
Danica Patrick |
||||
| 2004 | Tony Kanaan |
Andretti Green Racing | Dallara | Honda | Kosuke Matsuura |
Sam Hornish, Jr. |
||||
| 2003 | Scott Dixon |
Chip Ganassi Racing | G-Force | Toyota | Dan Wheldon2 |
Sarah Fisher |
||||
| 2002 | Sam Hornish, Jr. |
Panther Racing (2) | Dallara | Chevrolet | Laurent Rédon |
Sarah Fisher |
||||
| 2001 | Sam Hornish, Jr. |
Panther Racing | Dallara | Oldsmobile (5) | Felipe Giaffone |
Sarah Fisher |
||||
| 2000 | Buddy Lazier |
Hemelgarn Racing | Dallara | Oldsmobile | Airton Daré |
Al Unser, Jr. |
||||
| 1999 | Greg Ray |
Team Menard (2) | Dallara | Oldsmobile | Scott Harrington |
Scott Goodyear |
||||
| 1998 | Kenny Bräck |
A. J. Foyt Enterprises (2) | Dallara | Oldsmobile | Robby Unser |
Arie Luyendyk |
||||
| 1997 | Tony Stewart |
Team Menard | G-Force | Oldsmobile | Jim Guthrie |
Arie Luyendyk |
||||
| 1996 | Scott Sharp |
A. J. Foyt Enterprises | Lola | Ford-Cosworth | not awarded | not awarded | ||||
| Buzz Calkins |
Bradley Motorsports | Reynard | Ford-Cosworth | |||||||